[Randios]

Asia lip synced Don't Cha lol...so all that singing was for nothing.
Melissa R is a back up dancer now. but hopefully she'll become a solo artist...she already has fans

[Tara]

yeah.. i hope the best for Melissa R.. i hope she gets signed somewhere and somehow.. and its true.. when it comes to PCD its all about Nicole, and the rest of them are there just to be there; sad but true.. however congrats to Asia though

[orchid]

Congrats to Asia for winning man these rumor why theu have to be so real. I glad she won becasue I know Chelsea will not win becasue of her dancing and Mellisa well I thought she should win but just watching the last episode she looks like a mini-me of Nicole.

[lisa05]

i am so disappointed that asia won. well she performed well. yea i agree that melissa does look like nicole.

[orchid]

Yeah i guess Asia is the best performer out of the three girls but i surely do not like her voice.

[kimberly]

that guy from Geffen was not happy with the results...like the look on his face after Robin said Asia he was like i cant believe it...he never really liked asia....to me it seemed like he liked Melissa more....hopefully he signes her as a solo artist on Geffen

[<3_Jieb]

I totally agree with you guys about Asia! I wish Chelsea and Melissa.R the best! I loved Chelsea voice and the song she sing in the last episode and Melissa.R's too! She just shined!! I like them both so much! Asia seriously don't know how to sing!! Gosh hate her so freakin' muchies!!

[Randios]

it was unfair that Melissa and Chelsea had slow songs while Asia had an upbeat fast song. Even then i thought Asia's performance was the worst of the 3.
Melissa sounds exactly like Nicole when she sings..if you watch carefully you can see Ron whispering into Robin's ear "she sounds like Nicole" and Robin says "I know"
i think the reason Asia won is because Melissa is too similar to Nicole

[Jean]

I can't beleive that stupid Asia won. I wanted to slap the smile off her face when they announced that she won. I think the reason she only won was because they felt sorry for her b/c she has a daughter at home and it could help her out financially. Melissa R can sing and dance better than her.

[ceda_lee]

Randios, on Apr 26 2007, 03:09 AM, said:

it was unfair that Melissa and Chelsea had slow songs while Asia had an upbeat fast song. Even then i thought Asia's performance was the worst of the 3.
Melissa sounds exactly like Nicole when she sings..if you watch carefully you can see Ron whispering into Robin's ear "she sounds like Nicole" and Robin says "I know"
i think the reason Asia won is because Melissa is too similar to Nicole

I agree! And Melissa R said that when CWtv interviewed her too! I think Ron was rooting for Melissa R all the way...the look on his face wasn't too happy when Robin annouced that Asia was the winner...and Ron usually give Asia bad comments too...haha...Asia cannot sing, but she can scream, like desperately...haha...if they would have given Melissa R the upbeat song, she would have done even better than Asia!!

[mokka]

I agreed, I for should thought that Melissa will win because she can sing dance too.. Darn... i was upset when they announced Asia's name... dang...

[deKKbah]

Asia got major attitude and she won! I voted for melissa R. she gots more talent then asia did. But i guess good luck to her.

[Randios]

Melissa R even said that the reason she didn't win was because she looks similar to Nicole.

but there's rumors floating around that Robin didn't pick the winner, but the head of the record label came to the taping of the very last episode and just chose Asia out of the 3.
if that's true than there's really no point in the whole competition. Now there's a 2nd season.

[annea]

what!!!theres a second season?
they already found a backup dancer....what else are they looking for next?