[Sunyah]

Which version do you like or prefer? If anyone saw Hana Kimi Series.

Credit to: asianfanatics.net

Taiwanese version: Hana Kimi (staring Wu Ji Zun, Ella, ???)



Japanese version: Hana Kimi (staring: Oguri Shun, Maki Horikita, Ikuta Toma)

[Ana]

I didn't watch it but my sis say Taiwan one was better

[Sunyah]

The Taiwan version is better too. Ella look so much like a guy. hehe Love this Series but hate the really ending secen.

I haven't see the Japan version yet but I'm going too.

I hear that in the Japan version everyone found she was a girl.

[shampoo]

I rather watch a short version. I have watch neither but anyway lol I think Japanese will do a great job on it. Just like Metero Garden, I thought the Japanese one is just as good.

[YueRain]

I thought the Japanese version was better. Both versions were entertaining, but I preferred the way Maki played Mizuki.

[Karen]

the japanese version had more details. the taiwanese had a lot of funny scenes in it. i enjoyed both versions but i have to say that i like the taiwanese one better cuz it had jiro and wu chun in it.

both were good gotta give props to both of them!

[<3_Jieb]

I say the T-version. Wu Zun is so hot.. Ella looks so much like a guy no offense. lol, Jiro looks gay in that pic but he's cute.

My cousin has the J-version but I didn't bother to watch it since the female lead and the two other guys don't look too appealing to me.

[passionalee]

i vote Tai keke but my fren like the japan vers. just cuz the girl actully look more girl n less ugly ahah lol XDD i dink ella`s fine n prudy keke [ gotta still try to finish it ] i jus t;like watch scenes here nt here keke saw the eppy where Wu drank n kiss Ella ekke hecka nice lol

[shampoo]

passionalee, on Dec 12 2007, 04:24 AM, said:

i vote Tai keke but my fren like the japan vers. just cuz the girl actully look more girl n less ugly ahah lol XDD i dink ella`s fine n prudy keke [ gotta still try to finish it ] i jus t;like watch scenes here nt here keke saw the eppy where Wu drank n kiss Ella ekke hecka nice lol

I agreed with your friend. I like Maki better cuz she's more girly looking.

[``Wit LoVE]

i haven't watched dis yet but my cousin said da japenese one is better lolz...^^

This post has been edited by ``Wit LoVE: 12 December 2007 - 06:15 AM

[dlover]

I'll have to say the Japanese it better, but I love Jiro's role a whole lot better
I thought that his acting was cute the way that he express his "love" lol...
especially the scene where her friend came and visit and he started talking in English
"GYA, Gay you know..." lol...something along this line....hahaha..can't believe that i forgot it...

[greenapple2]

Overall I liked the taiwanese version more. But I liked the girl in the Japanese version. However, I thought Wu Chun and Jiro's role were better in the taiwanese version. But, I liked the other stuff like events that they had in the Japanese version. But... I liked both!!

[Sunyah]

I finish watching the Japanese version and I like the storing line and the music…how she cut her hair and what her reason. And how it show more of the three club and other thing to it.

But some other reason I didn’t like is that the girl, she still look like a girl even when she cut her hair. She doesn’t look to the part of a guy… (Just my opinion)….And it show to much of the three club than the two main leading. There wasn’t much sweet scene of the two leading and even when he found out she was a girl he didn’t care much until later toward the end. And the doctor he doesn’t look or act the part that he gay. Like in the Taiwanese version the doctor more conveniences he gay. Threw out the series it show more scene of the second leading guy and the leading girl which I think they should have got each other because some how I like them more as a couple than her with the leading guy…

Overall I love both series but I love the Taiwanese version more. Because of how Ella can conveniences she a guy and Wu Chun and Jiro's role were better and how Wu fall in love with Ella…

[Cecilia]

I have not seen the japanese version but anyway, reason why i like the taiwanese is b/c jiro is in there. ella is hahah, ugly like you gals say, she look very manly and her voice just add on to it. the japanese cover doesn't look so bad .. the tomboy girl is actually looking very cute like FON .. maybe someday when i'm back to the japanese phase, then i'll watch it..

[T3rRi]

I watch both versions and I have to say the Japanese version is way better! :tbs: